Alchemy Was always suspicious - the fear of the unrelatable

Alternate Proteins as Alchemy

Image Credit - Good Food Institute

“Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”
— Arthur C Clarke

“Alchemy”

may perhaps have been the precursor of Science. It certainly was considered suspicious except in fringe circles. Primarily, because it seemed so far removed from human comprehension but also, I posit, because it was so far removed from everyday use case . Why waste your time dreaming (scheming) up ways to transmute one elemental form into another when life, indeed, was of survival, and, there was so much “doing” needed to be done!

One would think that such feeling may have become archaic what with having extra bandwidth to let dreamers be, and, Science itself having become a valid pursuit of betterment. Yet, while the general acceptance of science, as not magic but grounded in the real, may have grown in correlation with it truthfulness and usefulness, we can see this suspicion still prevalent in many areas of technological advancement that are mostly inaccessible to the many.

This applies to a host of new technologies making a parade at this point of human evolution from crypto to food tech to AI to the multi(meta)verse.


I make the case today for at least one of the many - Alternative Animal Products.

The Problem …

Much of the negativity on alternative proteins not sourced from animals but masquerading as animals on a plate, has around about concerns of quality, let down on taste, lack of nutritional clarity and the fact that it is Processed, with the capital P. Plant based protein products particularly are saddled by the dual scarlet tags of taste and process. And, culture meat while not yet tested for taste carry the trifecta backlash of the other three.

Meanwhile, much of the response to the detractors has been focused on setting the record straight and right lining expectations mixed in with a heavy handed dose of shame and guilt.

You may say I’m a dreamer
But I’m not the only one
I hope someday you’ll join us
And the world will live as one
— John Lennon

What gets lost in all of this is Latent Fear that drives the pushback. A fear rooted in black magic and witchcraft - a possibly irrational and yet a very real one.

The Thinking …

Let’s step back.

Processed foods are no new concept.

I mean it is whole context of CPG with a market of over $1 Tn (yep, with a T). Except they really should be called “Conveniently Packaged (for you) Goods”. And there in lies the truth. The processed foods that we have thus far been buying have been those that we recognize not only as a product but also as a process. Given enough incentive/imeptus/initiative, we could possibly recreate all of the foods currently on the shelf ourselves, from that chicken thigh to can of beans. What the processing company from Tyson to Kraft did was to make it so we did not need to. Inherent in this was that we recognize the primary input ingredients and are familiar with the spectrum of output that we ingest. Inherent in this is also a certain nonchalance on what else, aka additives, are added to keep that “convenience” the leading value. They all carry the same burden of questionable nutritional {de}value and often a marked downtick of taste. And, yet these negative traits are not burdensome here at all.

It is all too much medicine to be food isn’t it?

I mean it belongs in a lab, a hospital, a place for the broken to be fixed!!

Making tissue from cells is also not new.

After all, this is the entire context of stem cell research, with a market size of $12 Bn in 2021. Their acceptance is because they are necessary, for survival via medical treatment. There is obviously regulation to ensure safety but even though the average recipient of the treatment is entirely unaware of the process, they are nevertheless, simply grateful for a chance of a cure.

People will accept anything that enables them to live {without pain}.

This is a character strength that has persistently exhibited in the bizarre eating behaviors of those who were caught unawares in situations without access to regular food, such as shipwreck, deserts etc. Expounding on the last, the extent to which a person may go to feed themselves, such as cannibalism, can sometimes be revolting but is conditionally seen as acceptable under the ‘extenuating’ circumstances.

That sets the stage to ask the question - Why then is there such a visceral reaction to the concept of Alternate Animal Products?

And, the answer to that is not really that it is unnatural. Or, that it is of questionable value. But rather it is the Unfamiliar and Unnecessary for survival. Plant based protein is like alchemical product created by transforming a humble plant product into a revered animal product through a process that is entirely unrelatable to the majority of meat consumers. For added irony, many of the meat eaters are possibly not consumers of, or even familiar with, the original plant inputs. On the cultured side, it is all too much medicine to be food isn’t it? I mean it belongs in a lab, a hospital, a place for the broken to be fixed.

Certainly not Affordable for All

A McKinsey study of consumer choices from 2020 showed people prized price and quality as most relevant in making meat purchase decisions.

Add to that, they are certainly not cheap. A McKinsey study of consumer choices from 2020 (highlight image above) showed people prized price and quality as most relevant in making meat purchase decisions. Dairy followed the same trend with “brand” completing a trifecta. While there may be some shifts in the two years since (and certainly within psychographic segments) the trend continues enmasse.

It is little wonder then that these products are viewed with suspicion, and combined with the marketing strategies currently used, alienated against. And, this is where the mode of marketing matters. Food is, more than simply fuel, often an identity.

  1. Challenging the way it is currently consumed, therefore the self itself, is strike 1.

  2. Offering a solution that is literally alchemy that nobody quite understands is strike 2.

  3. And for the kill, the levers of shame and guilt used to enforce acceptance is the quintessential strike 3.

What is lost in all this as well is the JOY. People who eat meat ENJOY eating meat. That singular positive emotion works to the exclusion of literally every other negative consequence, infamously including their own health.


The solution ?

Remarkably, would be to invest in creating connection and negating the negative messaging. As Adam Grant says in Think Again “Visions of Change are more compelling when they include visions of Continuity

Recreate the feeling of JOY

With the new products, encourage eaters to act from the space of self-interest rather than benefaction.

Make the right choice the easy choice.

This is certainly a time will tell solution where the process and regulation become mature enough for the price to be right and packaging effective.

“It is not from the benevolence (kindness) of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.”
— Adam Smith

(Re)Defining S-T-P for Digital

(Re)Defining S-T-P for Digital

The key in this is that this pull based approach allows the consumer to co-create their journey of discovery leading in to your product/service rather than being force fed and bombarded by “ME, ME, ME” ads that take a lot (attention, time, context) and give little (information, delight, entertainment).

Needless to say, ads no longer exist as singularities, particularly in digital space. They coexist within the context of (social media) Communities, (informative and co-created) Content and should be viewed as an additional channel of creating Connection.

Future of Food CPG Experience - The East/West Divide (?) in Food Perceptions

Future of Food CPG Experience - The East/West Divide (?) in Food Perceptions

Food is a complex subject that becomes complicated very easily. And, yet the basic desires of people are irrefutably simple and universal - to feel GOOD. Where good meets profitable is not a niche but a continuum often explored and understood through conversations and connecting rather than just statistical analysis.

My thoughts on the opportunities for Food CPG based on ethnographic and traditional research across the coasts of US.

Making Food Waste winnable

Making Food Waste winnable

Food-waste reduction has been treated as a step child in the opportunity space in food-tech with very little VC funding or government backing supporting innovation in this space. While its place in the global sustainability goals remains high, there is no real skin being added to the game of inventive techniques for waste management and prevention. 

The opportunities lie in understanding where within the range of possibilities may lie hidden gems that can display a tangible and immediate future accessible revenue pipeline. Largely, these involve initiatives that embrace wasted food as an asset, can mobilise and commercialize it with the sustainable goal acting as a causal effect. 

#5QTest: Is your PR an Investment or Expense?

#5QTest: Is your PR an Investment or Expense?

If you are small business or {worse} a startup, then the question of whether to hire a PR firm is probably something you are always grappling with. In my experience, PR has been a much maligned and under-executed tool in the marketer's basket. Few companies I have spoken to have good things to say about their PR experiences.

Take this #5QTest and find out where you stand. Answering these questions will also give you the ideas to improve your PR strategy, no matter how well or badly you score today. As a bonus, if you haven't thought about these questions before as part of your business strategy, now you know what to do!

Behold The Age of Robot Marketers!

Behold The Age of Robot Marketers!

Today, with the advent of "consumer centricity" along with the host of enabling technology advances the paradigm of storytelling comes under question. The biggest disruptors to the conventional marketing mix modeling are IoTs, free access to information and automated e-commerce. They have changed the process and intent of brand interaction, creating a distinct divide between the high and low involvement purchase decisions. 

In this new world, the marketer's role will be in close collaboration with product R&D teams to create tight product lines that are super quantified by market need. And, in telling a story and proving the differential within increasingly reduced attention spans. Marketing as a function will evolve into three distinct paths -

  1. Technical and data driven for majority of mass market category retail
  2. Emotional and data enabled for high value purchases
  3. Experiential for luxury and hospitality. 

Optimizing Ad ROI: Do You Know Your Un-Budgeables?

Optimizing Ad ROI: Do You Know Your Un-Budgeables?

BECAUSE AD SPEND ON UNBUDGEABLES IS A WASTE!

An UnBudgeable is a person whose opinion cannot be shifted in favor or your product or brand with any amount of pitch perfect ads served and completely viewed, in any context or delivery channel.

Consumers in these categories mimic your brand's target audience and therefore will be automatically included for ad delivery. However, these consumers are also primed psychologically to ignore and actively disconnect from your ads. The reason for this inflexibility is that the person is already locked in a non-corraborating behavior or a competitor with differential value and switching them is extremely expensive, for you and them.

Such UnBudgeable lock-ins categorize into three distinct groups. I also outline strategies to identify and isolate each type from your ad cohorts.

 

Brand Early, Brand Often, Brand Informative

Brand Early, Brand Often, Brand Informative

That is, in short, the key insight from The ARF Re:Think 2016 conference!

Numerous research by multiple parties has shown that digital ads, particularly, video ads are drastically sub-optimized for digital and many brands are still creating to the standards of TV and delivering across other channels. For effective ad engagement, this needs to change.

This article outlines 5 action items for creating impactful brand messaging on digital platforms.